Do You Think Your Pastor or a Staff Member Has a Mental Illness?
Spiritual environments can attract individuals seeking positions of power and authority. When a pastor or staff member struggles with undiagnosed mental illness, the entire congregation is at risk. Here is how to recognize the signs and protect your church.
Spiritual environments often attract individuals seeking positions of power and authority. Unfortunately, regardless of the denomination, some of these individuals are fundamentally unqualified to lead due to diagnosed or undiagnosed mental illness. When left unaddressed, placing a psychologically unstable individual in a position of unchecked spiritual authority is incredibly dangerous for the congregation.
The Consensus Among Ministry Leaders and Seminaries
This crisis of leadership mental health is well-documented by experts in spiritual and emotional health. As highlighted in Shepherds or Wolves?: Narcissism and the Crisis of Spiritual Leadership, the intersection of unchecked authority and psychological instability is devastating.
Dr. Chuck DeGroat, licensed therapist and author of When Narcissism Comes to Church, argues that narcissism within church leadership is an "us problem, not a them problem." DeGroat notes that toxic narcissism in a pastor often masks deep, compensatory shame. Such leaders require excessive admiration, possess a sense of entitlement, and demonstrate interpersonally oppressive behaviors. DeGroat warns that narcissistic leaders often live a "quadruple life" — a public self, private self, blind self, and undiscovered self — making it vital for congregations not to dismiss warning signs or relational violations.
Similarly, in The Emotionally Healthy Leader, Peter Scazzero emphasizes that the "false self" of a spiritually unhealthy leader often dresses up as success. Scazzero points out that a lack of emotional health leads to prioritizing results over communion and charisma over recognizing one's limits. He argues that becoming a better leader requires transforming this inner life and confronting beneath-the-surface issues, rather than relying on quick fixes.
To prevent these individuals from ever reaching the pulpit, many institutions now recognize that psychological evaluations are a "hidden key" to healthy seminary admissions. Seminaries increasingly use standardized psychological evaluations as an essential gatekeeping tool to identify blocks to growth, rigidity, or relationships that are too damaged to allow an individual to assume healthy leadership. When successful, these evaluations screen out applicants with severe psycho-sexual disorders or emotional instability, ensuring they do not take on the spiritual care of a congregation.
How to Remediate the Situation
1. Approach the Board Members Privately with Written Documentation
Do not rely on hearsay or emotional appeals. To effectively address the problem, approach the church board or elder team privately with concrete, written documentation. Keep a Log: Document specific incidents where the behavior of the senior pastor or staff member was highly questionable, erratic, or abusive. Focus on Behavior: Note dates, times, witnesses, and the exact nature of the behavior. Providing a factual, written record makes it much harder for leadership to dismiss your concerns as a simple personality conflict.
2. Impress Upon the Board the Widespread Psychological Damage
Church boards are often hesitant to act because they fear conflict or want to protect the institution's reputation. Highlight the Fallout: Explain that keeping an unstable leader in power causes severe psychological, mental, and spiritual trauma to the congregants. Identify Institutional Betrayal: Remind them that their primary fiduciary and spiritual duty is to shield the flock, not to protect a compromised pulpit.
3. Emphasize the Statistical Reality of Leadership Instability
To underscore the urgency, bring the broader national crisis to the board's attention. Over the past five years, more than 4,000 churches have permanently closed their doors in the United States. A significant portion of these closures is directly tied to leadership instability and the church board's failure to hold that leadership accountable.
Spotting the Signs: Ruminative Anger and Chameleon Denial
When evaluating the behavioral health of spiritual leadership, two destructive indicators of undiagnosed mental illness are ruminative anger cycles and chameleon denial.
Ruminative Anger Cycles
In a church setting, a pastor with this pattern may weaponize their authority to punish perceived enemies. Pulpit Bullying: Sermons are used to attack specific board members, staff, or parishioners indirectly. Inability to Resolve Conflict: Even after a disagreement is settled, the leader brings up old grievances, demonstrating an inability to process interpersonal friction. Cyclical Explosions: The environment feels like walking on eggshells, with intense, irrational outbursts over minor administrative issues.
Chameleon Denial
Chameleon denial is a defense mechanism where an individual rapidly shifts their narrative, persona, or memory of events to avoid accountability. The Shifting Narrative: A staff member will tell the church board one story, the associate pastors another, and the congregation something entirely different. Theological and Administrative Fluidity: They mold themselves to appease or manipulate whoever holds the most power in the room. Gaslighting the Flock: When a parishioner correctly points out a failure, the leader insists the conversation never happened, destabilizing the victim's sense of reality.
Access the Full Resource
Dr. Scott has prepared a comprehensive resource including a Confidential Incident Log Template and full remediation guidelines. Click the button below to access the complete document with scoring frameworks and step-by-step guidance.
Dr. Arthur George Scott
International Copyright, 2026